
All images were retrieved from Amazon.com .
Introduction
The mystery began for me when a fifth grade student asked me if I could show him where to find a “good” mystery book for him to check out of the library.
Immediately, I thought of Agatha Christie. I searched the shelves for mysteries by Agatha Christie, only to find the elementary school library did not have them. They were considered to be too adult for the students. But, wait a moment; hadn’t I begun reading Agatha Christie when I was in elementary school? No, wait. I think I was already in high school when I discovered her and her wonderful mysteries and detectives. For me, it had all started with Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? I had quickly moved on from there to Death on the Nile and The Man in the Brown Suit, and other thrilling mysteries by Agatha Christie and other mystery authors.
Nancy Drew and The Hardy Boys came to mind, next; but, they were so old. My mother had a collection of Nancy Drew mystery books when she was in elementary school. The middle school students of today might not find them so very interesting. So, where were the mysteries that “tweens”, 9-14-year olds would enjoy reading? What would they consider to be a “good” mystery story? I started thinking more and more about these questions and began to focus my mind on middle school-aged readers and fantasized about starting a mystery book club for this age group. The mystery book club could be open to all ages, but mostly focused on 9/10- to 14-year olds, or fifth to eighth grade students. What books should I include that the kids would enjoy reading and where would I find them? It was a mystery.
I interviewed several fifth grade students, figuring that they would be a good indicator of my target audience. I did the best I could to steer them to what I considered to be “good” mysteries, but they thought most of the books I recommended were too simple, too tame, or they had already read them, more than once. The kids told me they wanted something new, exiting, mysterious, interesting, and even a little bit challenging. They wanted something more interesting and exciting than Nancy Drew, or The Hardy Boys mystery series. They wanted something more mature and interesting than The Boxcar Children series, by Gertrude Chandler Warner, and something more challenging than the Magic Tree House series, by Mary Pope Osborn. Some of the fifth graders told me the aforementioned series of books were “boring” and “too babyish” for them, now that they were almost in middle school; although, later, a couple of them told me, in confidence, that they still read books from the Nancy Drew and Hardy Boys series, when they were not able to find anything else interesting to check out of the library. The students stated they felt that they were a little old for Nancy Drew, The Hardy Boys, or The Boxcar Children. Encyclopedia Brown, by Donald J. Sobol, and Cam Jansen, by David Adler and Susanna Natti, have both been recommended for 4-8-year olds, so they were also considered to be too “babyish” for this group. The fifth graders were, however, still too young for mysteries aimed at teens or young adults. These readers may have been into the double digits (as my 10-year old nephew says), but they were not quite teenagers or young adults, yet.
In my search for good mysteries for tweens, I interviewed librarians, booksellers and my fifth grade students about mysteries they had read and could recommend to middle school tweens. I soon learned that although many mystery books and/or books featuring young detectives have been written for younger elementary aged students, and for teens and young adults, very few are written specifically to satisfy kids between the ages of 10 and 14, the “tweens”. Some book lists claimed to show books for 9-12-year olds, but I thought the target group should be shifted up a bit. In my experience, there can be a big difference between a 9-old reader and an 11/12-year old reader; and some 13/14-year olds are not quite ready for books aimed at young adults, such as Never Trust a Dead Man, by Vivian Vande Velde, or What I Saw and How I Lied, by Judy Blundell.
So, what books to recommend to students of a certain age who want a good mystery?
Where were the books written for the 10-14-year olds of the 21st Century? Why were there not more of them written for this age group? It is a mystery. Loving a good mystery, myself, I put on my detective cap and began my search in earnest to find mystery and detective stories appropriate (interesting and challenging) for “tweens”.
I corralled more of the fifth graders and asked them to go through the shelves of the school library with me and show me the mystery or detective books they had already read and tell me which ones they had really enjoyed. Several of the students told me they had checked out books in the 39 Clues series several times, and that the first one, A Maze of Bones, by Rick Riordan, the author of the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series, was the best one. The fifth grade students mentioned Roald Dahl as being a favorite author, as well as Rick Riordan, and R. L. Stine.
The Artemis Fowl series, by Eoin Colfer, was a reported favorite mysterious spy series amongst many of the kids I spoke to about mystery books. This series is not strictly a mystery series but apparently was considered to be suspenseful and interesting to tweens. The most important characteristic of these books was that the protagonist was a 12-year old boy who appeared to be smarter, cleverer, and more ingenious than the adults with whom he comes into contact.
A mystery series that was mentioned by the fifth grade students I spoke with more than once was the Chet Gecko series, by Bruce Hale. Chet Gecko is not only a lizard and in the fourth grade, but he is also a private eye. Intrigued, I borrowed several books from the series from my local public library, and from the school library where I volunteer, and began to read them. I found that I thoroughly enjoyed the ones I read and went to a local bookstore to see if I could purchase a copy of one of them. To my surprise, none of the local Barnes & Noble Booksellers carried any of the Chet Gecko books. I asked a sales clerk to look up the series on her computer to see if I might find any of the books at any of the other Barnes & Noble stores in my area. Another surprise – the closest bookstore carrying this series was in New Jersey, clear on the other side of the country from Los Angeles, California. None of the B&Ns in other areas carried any of the Chet Gecko books!
It was another mystery.
(I did, eventually, find Chet Gecko books on Amazon.com, in my local public library and in the elementary school library where I volunteer.)
When I recommended The Invention of Hugo Cabret, by Brian Selznick, I learned that no one of the fifth grade students had ever checked the book out of the library, so they did not know how good it was. It appeared that the size, length and weight of the book had deterred them from reading it. They all thought it was too long, not realizing that parts of it are like a graphic novel with amazing pictures that tell parts of the story, so another difficulty was getting the information about mysteries for tweens to the kids, themselves. My idea for a mystery book club for tweens was sounding better and better.
I continued my detective work and ultimately came up with a list of twelve possible mysteries that tweens might enjoy reading and discussing and would be appropriate for their age group.
Annotated Bibliography
1. Abrahams, P. (2005). Down the rabbit hole: An Echo Falls mystery. NY: Harper Trophy.
Thirteen-year old Ingrid Levin, a talented soccer player and Sherlock Holmes fan, wins the coveted lead in a local theatre troupe’s production of Alice in Wonderland only to find herself caught up in a mystery involving the Prescott Players and Cracked-Up Katie, one of the town of Echo Falls’ leading eccentrics. After learning that her soccer cleats were found at the scene of Katie’s murder, Ingrid undertakes to solve the mystery while getting closer to the police chief’s son, avoiding the police learning about her connection with the murder victim, dealing with her mother’s constant concern about Ingrid’s retainer, and keeping up with play rehearsals. Will Ingrid be able to solve the mystery in time, or will she become another of the murderer’s victims?
School Library Journal recommended this book for 6-9th grades. Publishers Weekly recommended this book for ages 10 and up. Booklist recommended this book for grades 7-10. I recommend this book for more mature readers 12-14 and up, and think it may not be appropriate for 9-11-year olds.
2. DuPrau, J. (2003). The City of Ember. New York, NY: Random House, Inc.
In the underground city of Ember, twelve-year old Lina Mayfleet desperately wants to be assigned the job of messenger. Instead, she draws the dreaded job of Pipeworks laborer, which means she'll be working in damp tunnels deep underground. Doon Harrow draws messenger, but he wants to work on the pipes because that's where the generator is, so he asks Lina to trade. For as long as anyone can remember, the great lights of Ember have kept the endless darkness at bay. But now the lights are beginning to flicker and Doon has ideas about how to fix the failing generator. While he's deep in the underground tunnels, he discovers a secret room and strange markings on the walls of one of the tunnels. Lina finds a box that has been lost for many years and learns some things about how the city is being run and does not like what she has found. Food and medicines are running short, clothing is wearing out, and yet the mayor is still extremely fat and well-dressed. What is going on in the city of Ember? Together, Lina and Doon try to decipher the partially destroyed instructions, entitled “Directions for Egress”, left behind by Ember's creators over two hundred years ago and find a way out of the underground city to the world above.
This book has been recommended for readers 10-14.
3. Ayres, K. (1999). Voices at Whisper Bend: Mysteries through time. Middleton, WI: Pleasant Company Publications.
In 1942, twelve-year-old Charlotte and her classmates collect scrap metal for the war effort in their hometown in Pennsylvania only to have it mysteriously disappear from the school basement. Charlotte wants to do her part for the war effort after her brother Jim enlists in the Navy and her mother goes to work in the local war plant. Her father, the operator of a tugboat, guides boats towing war supplies up the Monongahela River. Charlotte comes up with the idea of enlisting her classmates to help her collect scrap metal, but her feelings of accomplishment regarding her project are short-lived when the metal is stolen from the school's basement. Charlotte’s determination to find the thief ultimately leads her out on the rain-swollen river at night, where she confronts not only the culprit, but also a fear that has haunted her.
This book has been recommended by the publisher for girls 10 and up. School Library Journal has recommended this book for grades 3-6.
4. Ayres, K. (2000). Under Copp’s Hill: Mysteries through time. Middleton, WI: Pleasant Company Publications.
In 1908, eleven-year-old Innie joins the library club at a settlement house that serves immigrant families of Boston's North End, but when items and money disappear from the settlement house, Innie's past as a troublemaker puts her under suspicion and she must try to solve the mystery herself.
This book has been recommended by the publisher for girls 10 and up. School Library Journal has recommended it for grades 4-6.
5. Balliett, B. (2004). Chasing Vermeer. NY: Scholastic Press.
Outsiders Petra and Calder become friends as they try to find out what happened to a missing Vermeer painting. Eleven year olds Petra Andalee and Calder Pillay may be in the same sixth grade class, but they barely know each other, and it is only after a near collision during a museum field trip that they discover their shared worship of art and their teacher Ms. Hussey. The kids’ growing friendship is strengthened when someone steals a valuable Vermeer painting, and when the thief leaves a trail of public clues in the newspaper, Petra and Calder decide to try and recover the painting themselves. Tracking down the Vermeer isn’t easy, as Calder and Petra try to figure out what a set of pentominos (mathematical puzzle pieces), a mysterious book about unexplainable phenomena, and a suddenly very nervous Ms. Hussey have to do with the centuries old painting. The book’s illustrator, Brett Helquist, has also hidden a secret pentomino message in several of the book’s illustrations for young readers to decode.
Booklist has recommended this book for grades 5-8.
6. Colfer, E. (2001). Artemis Fowl. NY: Talk Miramax Books/Hyperion Books for Children.
Twelve-year old Artemis Fowl is not only a boy genius and wealthy, he is also a criminal mastermind. In this, the first of the Artemis Fowl series, Artemis and his two trusty sidekicks hatch a cunning plot to divest the fairy folk of their pot of gold, even though he claims he isn't foolish enough to believe in any gold at the end of the rainbow nonsense. Artemis thinks that the only way to separate the little people from their stash is to kidnap one of them and wait for the ransom to arrive, but when the time comes to put his plan into action, he doesn't count on the appearance of the extra-small, pointy-eared Captain Holly Short of the LEPRecon (Lower Elements Police Reconnaissance) Unit--and her senior officer, Commander Root, who will stop at nothing to get Holly back from Artemis’ clutches.
Other titles in the Artemis Fowl series include, The Arctic Incident, The Time Paradox, The Atlantis Complex, The Eternity Code, The Lost Colony, The Opal Deception, and The Artemis Fowl Files.
Publisher’s Weekly has recommended this series for readers 12 and up, while Amazon.com has recommended it for 10 and up (or 9-12). After reading this book, I would have made the age range a little bit higher, but after talking to the fifth graders, it is actually appropriate. The Artemis Fowl series seems to be very popular, this year, especially with the 10-12 year olds.
7. Hale, B. (2001). Farewell my lunchbag: From the tattered casebook of Chet Gecko. San Diego: Harcourt, Inc.
In this third book of the series, Chet Gecko, fourth-grade private eye (and lizard), has been framed. Someone's been stealing the pickled spider eggs, cockroach quiche, happy-spider lasagna, deep-fried termites, and candied butterflies from the Emerson Hicky Elementary cafeteria, and it's not Chet. While on the case, this hard-boiled detective is tricked into eating a knockout pill bug muffin and when he comes to, he's surrounded by the remnants of cafeteria food, and no one, not Mrs. Bagoong, the giant iguana cafeteria lady, and not even his mockingbird partner, Natalie Attired, believes he's innocent. What's a gecko to do? A lot of detention for one thing, good detective work and digging into this mystery, as well as some fraternizing with Rocky Rhode, described as being a horned toad with a short fuse and a reputation for being up to no good.
Other titles in the Chet Gecko series include The Big Nap, The Chameleon Wore Chartreuse, Give My Regards to Broadway, The Hamster of the Baskervilles, Key Lardo, The Malted Falcon, Murder My Tweet, The Mystery of Mr. Nice, The Possum Always Rings Twice, This Gum for Hire, and Trouble is My Beeswax.
This book series has been recommended for 9-12-year olds.
8. Howe, D. & J. (1979). Bunnicula: A rabbit tale of mystery. NY: Atheneum Books for Young Readers.
One night, while out at the movies with their parents, Toby and Peter Monroe find a small rabbit that they name Bunnicula after the movie they were watching, Dracula. Pretty soon after the Monroe’s bring Bunnicula home strange things begin happening, including mysteriously white vegetables that appear in the refrigerator and hidden behind Bunnicula’s cage. Is it possible that the little bunny rabbit that Toby sat on in the movie theatre could be a vampire? This story is humorously told from the viewpoint of the Monroe family’s other pets, a dog named Harold and a cat named Chester, as they try to figure out an answer to the mystery of Bunnicula and the white vegetables.
Also see Bunnicula Strikes Again, and Bunnicula Meets Edgar Allan Crow, both by James Howe.
This book has been recommended by the publisher for children 8-12. I recommend this book for younger tweens as it may be too tame for older children.
9. Konigsburg, E.L. (1967). From the mixed-up files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler. NY: Scholastic Inc. [Republished by Atheneum in 2007.]
This book is a classic that is still popular today. Straight “A” student, and oldest of four children, Claudia Kincaid decides to run away from home to teach her parents a lesson about taking her for granted. She convinces her younger brother, Jamie, who has money, to run away with her to the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City where, once settled into the museum, the children have adventures that many children would enjoy, hiding from security guards, taking baths in the museum fountain, and sleeping in hundred year old beds. Before they know it, Claudia and Jamie find themselves caught up in the mystery of an angel statue that the museum purchased at an auction for a bargain price of $250. The statue is possibly an early work of the Renaissance master Michelangelo, and therefore worth millions. Is it, or isn't it? Claudia is determined to find out. Her detective work leads Claudia to Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler, the remarkable old woman who sold the statue to the museum.
This book has been recommended for ages 9-12.
10. Riordan, R. (2008). The maze of bones: 39 clues no. 1. NY: Scholastic Inc.
Following the death of their Aunt Grace, eleven-year old Dan Cahill and his fourteen-year old sister, Amy, are faced with an unusual choice. They are told they will inherit one million dollars or participate in a perilous treasure hunt. Since members of the Cahill family have determined the course of history for centuries this quest's outcome will bring the winners great power and ultimately affect all of humankind. Dan and Amy decide to accept the treasure hunt challenge, and set off to compete against other Cahill teams, who will stop at nothing to win, to decipher the first of 39 clues. Working together to solve puzzles and survive dangers Dan and Amy first find themselves on the trail of family member Ben Franklin and then continue on to find the next clue in order to solve the mystery and find the treasure.
The books in the series were written from 2008-2010 and authors of the other books in the series include Peter Lerangis, Jude Watson, Patrick Carmen, Linda Sue Park, Margaret Petersen Haddix, and Gordan Korman.
Recommended by School Library Journal for grades 4-7, and by Publishers Weekly for 9-12-year olds.
11. Vande Velde, V. (1999). There’s a dead person following my sister around.
Eleven-year-old Ted's biggest problem is not his annoying brother Zach, his social studies report on Luxembourg, or his stuck-up cousin Jackie, it is that he has ghosts in his house and they are following Ted’s five-year-old sister, Vicki, who is the first to see them. They make her so nervous, she starts keeping a hammer under her pillow for protection. Then, Ted dreams of mud, drowning and cobwebby fingers touching his face. Naturally, their parents don't believe these ghostly accounts of undead residents, so the children are on their own to do the detective work. The ghosts soon progress to the usual haunting activities of slamming doors, stealing keys and tipping over school projects. They appear on cable TV and even show up in a museum elevator. But why? Only when Ted unravels a mystery involving the Underground Railroad and reveals the ghosts' identities can peace be restored.
School Library Journal has recommended this book for 9-12-year olds (4th-7th grades).
12. Wells, R. (2010). On the Blue Comet. Somerville, MA: Candlewick Press.
Eleven-year old Oscar Ogilvie and his father love trains and the magic they evoke. Oscar and his father spend many hours together building just the right setting for their model trains in the basement of their house. Sometimes, Oscar puts his head down on the train layout and imagines what it would be like to ride the trains as they go around and around the track. After the Wall Street Crash of 1929, Oscar’s father loses his job and must sell their home and their treasured trains in order to afford to go to California to seek work. Oscar is sent to live with his humorless aunt Carmen and his younger cousin, Willa Sue. One night, while visiting his model trains and his friend, Harry Applegate, Oscar is involved in a bank robbery. Without thinking, and to escape the bank robbers, Oscar jumps and suddenly finds himself riding the real Blue Comet train heading for California, along with a mysterious but very kind young drifter. How did Oscar get on the train? Did he shrink down and is he riding his own model train, or did he enter some kind of time pocket, such as Oscar’s mathematician friend, Harry Applegate, has described. Could he really be riding on the actual Blue Comet and heading for adventure? What will happen when Oscar gets to California?
Booklist has recommended this book for grades 5-8. Amazon has recommended this book for grades 4-6. Library School Journal has recommended this book for grades 4-7.
Appendix I – Further Reading
Other mystery series/books aimed at this age group:
Avi. (2009). Murder at midnight. NY: Scholastic Press.
Bunting, E. (1992). Coffin on the case. NY: Harper Trophy.
Dixon, F.W. (1929). The secret of the caves (Hardy boys, book 7). NY: Grossett & Dunlap.
Gutman, D. (2011). The genius files: Mission unstoppable. NY: Harper.
Jonell, L. (2009). The secret of Zoom. NY: Square Fish/Henry Holt and Company.
Keene, C. 1946). The mystery of the tolling bell: Nancy Drew mystery stories, no. 23. NY: Grossett & Dunlap.
Marsh, C. (2003). The White House Christmas mystery. (Real Kids: Real Places – America’s National Mystery Book Series). Peachtree City, GA: Gallopade International.
Selznick, B. (2007). The invention of Hugo Cabret. NY: Scholastic Press.
Stewart, T.L. (2007). The mysterious Benedict Society. NY: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers.
Tinti, H. (2008). The good thief. NY: Dial Press/Random House, Inc.
Wallace, B.B. (2006). Sparrows in the Scullery. Lincoln, NE: Author’s Guild Backinprint.com/iUniverse, Inc.

