Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Behind the Lions: Anne Carroll Moore






“Hers was a brilliant sun, and the satellites orbiting around it rejoiced in its brilliance and governed themselves accordingly, but certain planets moving beyond that sun’s circadian rhythms felt themselves deprived of an illumination which yet lay within their reach.” (Sayers, 1972, p. 102.)



Anne Carroll Moore, circa 1930s. Photo retrieved from http://kids.nypl.org/parent/ocs_centennial_acm.cfm.


Abstract:

Anne Carroll Moore was a major force in the early development of youth librarianship and children’s library services. An avid reader from a young age, Anne Moore grew up to become the Supervisor of Children’s Rooms at the New York Public Library, the Superintendant of Work with Children of the New York Public Library, a Doctor of Letters from Pratt Institute, and teacher and mentor to another great woman in the history of youth librarianship, Frances Clarke Sayers, as well as encourager of authors and staunch reviewer of books for children and someone who he was instrumental in the development of the art of writing and illustrating good books for children.

Introduction:

Anne Carroll Moore has been said to have “more or less invented the children’s library” while at the New York Public Library. (Lepore, 2008). She also created a reading room for older children, first at Pratt and then at the New York library, (Sayers, 1972, pp. 69), anticipating young adult/ teen services in libraries; wrote essays and reviews on children’s literature, children’s illustrators and children’s authors; worked to open up libraries to children of all ages, and encouraged children and teachers to visit the library. (Sayers, 1972). It has been said that she was a formidable presence, despite her diminutive size, and if she liked a book and recommended it then librarians and teachers across the United States, as Great Britain and France and other parts of Europe, would purchase the book for their libraries and recommend it to children and their parents; but if she did not like it, she would stamp it with the phrase “Not recommended for purchase by expert”, and that would most likely be the end of it. (Lepore, 2008). Anne Carroll Moore wrote and edited several books and penned many essays and literature reviews in her lifetime. She was also written about, most notably by one of her fellow children’s librarians, Frances Clarke Sayers.

Annie Carroll Moore was born on July 12, 1871 in Limerick, Maine. In her biography entitled Anne Carroll Moore: A Biography, fellow librarian and successor to Miss Moore at the New York Public Library, Frances Clarke Sayers, describes her subject as being “the cherished only daughter” (Sayers, 1972, pp. 50) and youngest of ten children. Most of her brothers were already grown and out of the house by the time little Annie Carroll Moore was born, and two previous girls had both died in infancy. Annie reportedly was named for a maiden aunt, but later changed her name to Anne so as not to be confused with another Annie Moore who was also a teacher and author.

Anne apparently enjoyed spending time with her father and had a large extended family, including nieces, great nieces and cousins, with which she stayed in contact throughout much of her life, even taking a couple of her nieces, in to live with her after the death of their father, one of her older brothers. Later on in her life, she also allowed other relatives to stay with her.

Storer Lunt, one of Anne’s cousins, was encouraged to go into publishing and became head of W. W. Norton & Company. According to Sayers (2008), in him Anne “found an ongoing fervor for books and reading that matched her own and a mind honed to the sharp edge of argument and debate in matters of critical opinion.” This apparently was a foreshadowing of Anne Carroll Moore’s future influence in the world of literature for children, as a critic, author, essayist, librarian, and teacher.

Anne reportedly developed a love of nature, especially flowers, which, according to Sayers (1972), she utilized in her creation of ideal library spaces for children when she began working at the Pratt Free Library and then later at the New York Public Library. Anne Carroll Moore enjoyed reading but did not see herself as a “bookish child”; however, she was sent away to school at the age of ten to Alderwood Academy. She later went on to Bradford Academy, from where she was later awarded the Jean Pond Trophy in 1952, and then to library school at the Pratt Institute. Anne Carroll Moore was the first woman to receive a Diploma of Honor from Pratt. Miss Moore was also made a Doctor of Letters in 1955 in another ceremony at the Pratt Institute. (Sayers, 1972).

Following her graduation from the Pratt Library School, in Brooklyn, New York, Anne Carroll Moore was invited back to head up the new Children’s Library of Pratt Institute, after one of her classmates had to back out of the job. Miss Moore reportedly spent ten years there, developing her ideas for a good children’s library and lived “a quiet congenial life with the seamy side underneath”. (Sayers, 1972, p. 58). It was while working at Pratt that she developed her “major triad”, which reportedly was “children, books and pictures” (Sayers, 1972, p. 63), and opened up the shelves for use by the children, created a reading room for older children, and created the pledge that each child had to make upon entering the library for the first time and entered their name in the register book. This pledge was later to be utilized and refined when Anne Carroll Moore was hired on to be the first Supervisor of the Office of Work with Children at the New York Public Library, in New York City. (Sayers, 1972, pp. 67-68).

Upon entering the library, the children would be asked to recite the pledge and to sign the register. The librarians were told by Moore to take this ceremony very seriously so that the children would also take it very seriously.

When I write my name in this book I promise to take good care of the books I use at home and in the library, and to obey the rules of the library. (Sayers, 1972, p. 68).

It was interesting to read Frances Clark Sayers’ biography of Anne Carroll Moore, written in mostly admiring tones, with a few comments about Miss Moore’s “high-handed arrogance” that at times “took command” (Sayers, 1972, p. 49), and then compare it with the New Yorker article entitled, “The Lion and the Mouse”, in which Mrs. Sayers had less kind things to say about her predecessor. According to the author of the New Yorker article, Jill Lepore (2008), Sayers was dismayed by how Moore, although retired, would maintain her grip on power at the New York Public Library by showing up to meetings and trying to run them. In her article, Lepore (2008) quotes Mrs. Sayers as stating: “No matter where you held them, she was there”, as well as admitting in an oral history effected at U.C.L.A. in the 1970’s “that she found it all but impossible to stand up to Moore, who made her life ‘an absolute hell’ by refusing to cede control.”

The main subject of Lepore’s article is the conflict between Anne Carroll Moore and author E.B. White over his first book for children, Stuart Little. According to Lepore (2008), after seven months of badgering Mr. White to write a book for children, Miss Moore lambasted it. She reportedly declared, “I never was so disappointed in a book in my life.” (Lepore, 2008). She stamped it “Not recommended for purchase by expert”, and discouraged librarians from ordering it for their libraries. Frances Clarke Sayers reportedly refused to buy the book for her library, as well, but was later found to have a copy hidden underneath her desk and was convinced to put it on the shelves of the Children’s Room of the New York Public Library. (Lepore, 2008). Moore was able, however, to use her influence and strong opinions to deny Stuart Little the Newbery Medal, and the book was not even one of the four runners-up for the honor. Moore apparently did not like White’s second book for children, Charlotte’s Web, either (Lepore, 2008), although, this time, children, librarians and teachers prevailed despite her dislike and the book became a success and continues to be a favorite with children and adults to this day.

In her book, New Roads to Childhood, Anne Carroll Moore collected some of her reviews and essays regarding issues pertaining to children’s literature and published them all together. Her subjects included her opinions regarding Illustrating Books for Children, children’s book authors, Story-Telling and the Art of Reading, recommendations for holiday reading, Recent Italian Children’s Books, The Creative Spirit in America, and others. In her chapter on Writing for Children, Moore states:

New writers with ideas and originality in expressing them were sorely needed in the field of children’s books. Writers of promise are bound to lose both spontaneity and dramatic force under pressure of writing a sequel or a series following a single successful book. It is a wise publisher who reminds himself of the six years between “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland” and “Through the Looking-Glass” before he asks an author to “do it again.” (Moore, 1923, p. 64).

One of Anne Carroll Moore’s favorite people seemed to have been Marie Shedlock, an apparently exciting storyteller whom Moore discovered and showcased at the New York Public Library many times. Both Frances Clarke Sayers and Moore discuss Shedlock in their books, New Roads to Childhood (Moore, 1923) and Anne Carroll Moore: A Biography (Sayers, 1972), respectively. In the chapter entitled, “Unusual Books”, Moore recommends several books and stories of which most readers might not have heard, such as “Fairies and Chimneys”, and “The Treasure of the Isle of Mist”, as well as some old favorites such as “The Story of Dr. Dolittle” and tales by Hans Christian Anderson, who also seemed to be a favorite of Anne Carroll Moore. (Moore, 1923, p. 92-102).

According to the New York Public Library’s webpage entitled “Anne Carroll Moore: Our First Supervisor of Work with Children”:

Moore encouraged events and celebrations planned around special subject areas. These events were also designed to develop a love of reading. She hosted a celebration in the children's room for St. Nicholas' Eve every December 5th. She was a strong advocate for storytelling as a library event. Walter de la Mare, Ludwig Bemelmans and Carl Sandburg were among the authors who presented at the Central Children's Room. She was most influential in the promotion of storyteller Marie Shedlock's career in the United States, as well as in France. For five years she assisted with booking Shedlock's engagements and planning her United States itinerary. (Mucci, 2004).

Moore wrote two children's books of her own. Both of her books were about her constant companion, Nicholas, an eight-inch wooden doll with articulated arms and legs, which could stand all by himself, without anyone holding him. The doll reportedly was purchased, at Bloomingdale's, by a library employee during the 1920 Christmas season. The two books about the little, wooden doll were called Nicholas: A Manhattan Christmas Story (1924) and Nicholas and the Golden Goose (1932). The first children’s book was a runner-up for the Newbery Medal in 1925. (Eileen, H., 2009). Nicholas was a constant presence in the library, and was frequently a subject in Moore's correspondence. (Mucci, 2004). According to the article from The New Yorker, by Jill Lepore, however, no one missed Nicholas when Moore accidentally left him in a taxi. (Lepore, 2008).

In the Appreciation that Anne Carroll Moore wrote for the book The Art of Beatrix Potter, she wrote about her efforts at the Pratt Institute Free Library in Brooklyn, New York:

Enjoyment of books within the library itself was one of the main features of this children’s Library. The freedom from any restriction of age or custom gave parents as well as young children a natural free access to books in a homelike setting. A children’s library was a new idea and picture books played a major role in its development. (Moore, 1972, p. xiii).

In her Appreciation, Moore expressed her opinion regarding Beatrix Potter and her work:

I have always been glad that my own first impressions of Beatrix Potter as an artist were taken from The Tailor of Gloucester and from Squirrel Nutkin, published in the same year, rather than from Peter Rabbit. The individuality of character and setting of each little book remains clearer in mind in consequence and the value of her contribution to children’s books, her own direct communication of the natural world to children, more fully appreciated. To me they have always been Beatrix Potter’s books rather than the Peter Rabbit books. (Moore, 1972, p. xiii).

Anne Carroll Moore went on to relive her visits to Beatrix Potter’s farm in England and to describe what she saw and experienced there. The two prominent women, both of them involved in the world of children’s literature, reportedly became very good friends and thoroughly enjoyed each other’s company.

Moore also wrote in her Appreciation about American publishers beginning to pay attention to the idea that books for children, with their colorful illustrations, could be considered to be works of art. She also talked about her contributions to the development of children’s services in libraries and her belief that the American children’s library becoming a model for libraries around the world. She claimed that the American children’s library came to be regarded as “a new idea in education” for other countries, and implied that this prompted the opening of the first European library for children in Stockholm. (Moore, 1923, p. xiv).

In Writing and Criticism: A Book for Margery Bianco, Anne Carroll Moore edited a series of essays and remembrances of the author and critic Margery Bianco, better known as Margery Williams, the author of The Velveteen Rabbit, Poor Cecco, The Little Wooden Doll, The Skin Horse, and other stories. In the chapter entitled, “Margery Williams Bianco”, Moore wrote in glowing terms of the woman she considered to be an artist and friend and compared to Hans Christian Andersen. High praise indeed from Anne Carroll Moore. (Moore, 1951, pp. 3-21).The chapter concluded with a chronological list of Books by Margery Williams Moore and Books Translated by Margery Bianco.

Anne Carroll Moore was responsible for hiring the first Latina librarian in the United States, Pura Belpre (Eileen H., 2009), for whom the Belpre Award is named .

The Pura Belpré Award, established in 1996, is presented to a Latino/Latina writer and illustrator whose work best portrays, affirms, and celebrates the Latino cultural experience in an outstanding work of literature for children and youth. It is co-sponsored by the Association for Library Service to Children (ALSC), a division of the American Library Association (ALA), and the National Association to Promote Library and Information Services to Latinos and the Spanish-Speaking (REFORMA), an ALA affiliate.

The award is named after Pura Belpré, the first Latina librarian at the New York Public Library. As a children's librarian, storyteller, and author, she enriched the lives of Puerto Rican children in the U.S.A. through her pioneering work of preserving and disseminating Puerto Rican folklore.

The award is now given annually. It was given as a biennial award from 1996 through 2008. (ALA, 2006).


Summary:

After reviewing all of these resources regarding Anne Carroll Moore, I have come to the conclusion that she was a very talented, creative, ambitious, and tenacious woman who also happened to have a sure opinion and very little fear of expressing it out loud. She was a powerful influence and force to be reckoned with and did a lot to promote the development of appropriate services and good books for children in libraries and in the world of publishing. Anne Carroll Moore was mostly a force for good, but could also negatively influence other librarians and school teachers, as well as publishers, authors and readers.

In her lifetime, Anne Carroll Moore accomplished much. She was the head of the new Children’s Library at the Pratt Institute for ten years. She was the first Supervisor of the Office of Work with Children at the New York Public Library, where she hired and trained children’s librarians, including women, and oversaw the purchasing of books. She planned places for children to find good books and read them, on furniture that fit them, at several libraries in the New York area. She created a Reading Room for older children where they could peruse reference materials. She encouraged the people who ran libraries at the beginning of the 20th Century to extend the borrowing privileges for children and created a pledge that each child coming to the library was expected to honor. She traveled to schools and met with teachers and students and encouraged them to come and visit the library. She was awarded an Honorary Degree and made a Doctor of Letters by the Pratt Institute. The University of Maine also awarded her the degree of Doctor of Letters, and she was given the Regina Medal of the Catholic Library Association. (Mucci, 2004). She also received the first Constance Lindsay Skinner Gold Medal from the Women’s National Book Association and the Bookseller’s League of New York. (Eileen H., 2009).

Anne Carroll Moore was apparently loved by many, and disliked by a few, as most great people are and have been. She obviously stepped on some toes along the way, and found it difficult to let go of her baby, the Children’s Rooms at the New York Public Library. She never married, but helped raise several of her nieces, and some of her great nieces, as well. She had both a positive and a negative impact on the world; but, it seems that little Annie Carroll Moore, the only surviving daughter of ten children, definitely left her mark on the world when she left it, in January, 1961. Because of her, children are allowed in libraries and are allowed to check out books on a regular basis. Because of her, there are youth librarians and children and teen/young adult services in public libraries in the United States and other parts of the world. Because of her, good books have been and will continue to be published and children’s books are considered to be works of art, with awards being given out to honor them and the people who write and illustrate them. Her legacy will live on as long as there are libraries and books written and published for children to read and have read to them.

Bibliography

About the Belpré Medal. (2006, July 20). American Library Association.
Retrieved from
http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/alsc/awardsgrants/bookmedia/ belpremedal/belpreabout/index.cfm.

Eileen H. (2009.). Anne Carroll Moore. PB Library History Timeline. PBWorks. Retrieved from http://libraryhistory.pbworks.com/w/page/16964610/Anne-Carroll-Moore.

Lepore, J. (2008, July 21). The lion and the mouse: The battle that reshaped children’s literature. The New Yorker. Retrieved from http://www.newyorker.com/ reporting/2008/07/21/08072fa_fact_lepore?currentPage=all.

Moore, A. C. An appreciation. (1972). In Linder, L. & Herring, W. A. (Eds.) The art of Beatrix Potter (pp. ix –xxvi). London, England: Fredrick Warne & Co. Ltd.

Moore, A. C. (1923). New roads to childhood. New York, NY: George H. Doran Company.

Moore, A. C. & Miller, B. M. (Eds.). (1951). Writing and criticism: A book for Margery Bianco. Boston, MA: The Horn Book, Inc.

Mucci, J. (2004, May). Anne Carroll Moore: Our first supervisor of work with children. On-lion for kids!: The New York Public Library. Retrieved from http://kids.nypl.org/parents/ocs_centennial_acm.cfm.

Sayers, F. C. (1972). Anne Carroll Moore: A biography. New York, NY: Athenaeum.


No comments:

Post a Comment