Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Hanging Out with Fifth Grade Boys

Photo taken by the author with permission from B.S.R.


Not too long ago, I found myself wondering about the minds of fifth grade boys, one day. Perhaps it was because my nephew is one, or perhaps it was because the fifth grade boys at the elementary school where I volunteer in the library always seem to overrun my thoughts as they do the library each Thursday afternoon, just after one p.m. (Here, for your consideration, a group of fifth grade boys from Los Angeles, California.) I found myself wondering some things about them. What are they interested in? What do they do with their time? What video and computer games do they like to play? Does playing video/computer games take the place of reading, or do they still like to read? If they do still like to read, then what kinds of books do they like to read and check out of the school library? I also wondered if their choice in computer games might influence their choice in reading material; so, I decided to do a little research and ask them some questions.
Group Interviews and Observations
It was on a sunny day, not unlike many of the days in Southern California when I traveled to where I knew they would be – the school library. No, that was not what happened. One of the fifth grade classes has a standing appointment to have library time just after one o’clock p.m. every Thursday and I decided to study some of the students in that class.
The boys I chose to observe and interview ranged in age from ten to eleven years old. There were about five or six of them who came consistently, week after week, although sometime these were joined by the rest of their class which included approximately thirteen boys in all. The boys’ ethnicities and cultural identifications included Chinese American, European American (both Western and Eastern), African American, Persian American, and mixed ancestry. They were mostly of average height for ten and eleven year olds, except for one. He was a little short and seemed to make up for his lack of height by being the loudest of the bunch. They dressed pretty normally for boys of their age, faded blue jeans, a little big in the waist and saggy, multicolored sneakers with very thick soles, t-shirts either plain or with catchy or cute phrases or and logos on them, and the occasional baseball cap or yarmulke, in the case of the devout.
As the boys searched through the library shelves for the one book per week they were allowed to check out from the school library, whenever I was needed to help them find “a good book”, or during check-in and check-out sessions, I talked with them, asked them questions, and listened to their chattering conversations about what books they liked best to read and the computer and video games that they liked to play.
I learned that one of the most popular games the fifth grade boys enjoyed playing was Poptropica. This is a game with different levels and different islands with different adventures and mysteries to solve and that gets ever more difficult with each island. Poptropica adventures range from early America to medieval times to outer space and allow the players to pretend they are comic book superheroes, spies, space explorers, anthropologists, time travelers, or many other characters, complete with costume changes and virtual game rooms where they can play games with other Poptropica players. Many of the island scenarios have scientific and historical facts woven into them, and there is even one island adventure that involves learning about different historical figures such as Leonardo DaVinci and Thomas Alva Edison. It is in essence a role-playing game.
Another favorite game with the fifth grade boys I studied was Wizards 101. In this game, the characters appeared to be more realistically animated. The players have to learn magic, earn money and points, and battle monsters and other wizards. I listened to the boys describing how to play and it seemed quite complicated to me.
Several of the boys stated on more than one occasion that they were Pokémon fans, but few actually played any of the Pokémon computer games. They reported that they mostly liked to collect the cards and action figures and to have mock Pokemon battles with other boys on the playground during recess and lunch. The trading of cards appeared to be a very serious activity to some of the boys I studied.
I learned that the boys like games that allow them to be someone else for a while and games that have danger, mystery, action, and excitement in them. Many of them like games that involve magic and wizards or dragons and sword fighting. They like games in which the player has to figure something out or has to learn a new skill in order to complete tasks.
As far as their reading preferences, one of the boys usually asks after about ten to twenty minutes of searching the shelves of the school library if I can recommend a “good book”. He told me once that he likes “a good mystery”. He is the one who introduced me to Chet Gecko, fourth grade private eye. They boys in Mr. W.’s fifth grade class tended to check the same books out over and over again, despite hard work by the librarian and her assistant (yours truly) to suggest something new and exciting for them to try. The boys talked with me about their favorite books and why they like them so much. For the most part, they seemed to enjoy reading the same kinds of books as the video and computer games that they like to play on their computers and Nintendo DSs. They also like spy stories, such as can be found in the Artemis Fowl series, by Eoin Colfer. Another favorite is books about Star Wars, some of them cannot seem to get enough of going through these huge books with complicated technical drawings of various aspects of the Star Wars universe, week after week. They, too, barely spend time on the bookshelves of the school library.
The Percy Jackson & the Olympians series of books, by Rick Riordan, are also very popular with these fifth grade boys. Many of them stated they are looking forward to the new series of books by Riordan, including The Red Pyramid, book one of The Kane Chronicles, and The Lost Hero, book one of The Heroes of Olympus series. The Harry Potter series, by J.K. Rowling, also is almost never on the shelves as the fifth graders keep renewing them, sometimes trading them with one another at the checkout desk.
Individual Interview
In addition to observing and interviewing the boys from Mr. W.’s fifth grade class, I also individually interviewed one of the boys on more than one occasion. This particular boy was a member of Mr. W.’s class, but rarely joined the others during their weekly Thursday session in the school library. For the purposes of this paper, I shall call him B.S.R. During our interviews and interaction sessions, with the permission of his mother and father, I asked B.S.R. a series of questions about his game playing activities and his reading preferences.
The following are some of the questions I put to him during our first, official interview.
What kinds of computer and/or video games do you like playing?
What about these games do you like? What don’t you like about them (if anything)?
What kinds of books do you like to read?
What about these kinds of books do you like best? What kinds of books don’t you like reading?
What similarities do you see between the games you like to play and the books you like to read?
What differences between the games you like to play and the books you like to read are you aware of (if any)?
Do you ever read graphic novels, comics or manga? (Do you know what manga is?)
B.S.R. told me that he usually plays games on his Nintendo DS or on the computer. He told me he likes Pokémon because it’s fun, all new stuff, new moves, although he did not understand it at first. Now, he is battling and likes finding new Pokémon. He told me he likes it because the story is fun and you get to battle bad guys. As the player goes along battling, new Pokémon are found and earned and the adventure gets better and better. B.S.R. does not like that once you do something it can’t be undone and it is too easy to make mistakes. In order to learn a move you have to make space.
B.S.R. told me he likes Poptropica because of the adventure involved and figuring stuff out in order to complete one island and move on to the next. What he does not like is that it is too easy to get frustrated and that is why he likes the websites that offer cheats for players to use to get through the different sections and accomplish the tasks required to move on.
B.S.R. told me he likes Wizards 101 because of the magic and he can learn new spells, can go on quests to get better spells, wands, and level up. Again, he likes the adventure of the game and pretending to be someone else, in the game. He does not like that in Wizards 101 players often have to spend their own, real money which then transforms into crowns (money) in the game. (I personally observed B.S.R. becoming extremely frustrated by Wizards 101 while I was watching him play the game and I believe that that may also be a part that he does not like about this particular game, but I could be wrong.)
The books that B.S.R. professed to enjoy are ones about magic, adventures, and with lots of action, with a comic or funny side to them. His favorite series are Rick Riordon’s Percy Jackson & the Olympians books because they are about mythology. His told me he does not like reading history, non-fiction or biographies. He does not consider books about mythology to be history or non-fiction. He was able to see a similarity in the games he likes to play and the books he likes to read – both should have magic, adventure and mystery.
When asked about whether or not he has ever read graphic novels, comic books or manga, B.S.R. needed to have them described to him before he was able to answer. No, he had never heard the term manga before and did not know about graphic novels. It turns out, according to what he told me during our interviews, that he has read all of the Bone books. He flat out told me he does not like comics, except in the Sunday newspaper. I told him about some of the graphic novels and manga I read as part of a class I took last summer, and I recommended that he read the Knights of the Lunch Table series. He responded, “Knights of the lunch table – funny. It’s just like knights of the round table.”
We had a very nice discussion about graphic novels, comic books and manga and B.S.R. told me that he thinks his feelings about comics might have changed and he might give them a try. Soon after our talk, B.S.R. began reading Pokémon graphic novels, which in appearance border on manga.
Another discussion that we had during our interviews and my observation sessions with B.S.R. was about how Percy Jackson & the Olympians: The Lightning Thief was changed when it went from being a book to being a movie up on the big screen. B.S.R. voiced his opinions about how the filmmakers changed one of his favorite books. He told me about how he felt that “They cut off a lot of things. It changes everything around. Not in his backpack. [the stolen lightning bolt]. Percy doesn’t fight Luke.” He seemed very upset and to take it very personally that the movie was so different from the book.
I asked B.S.R. if I as part of my research I could observe him playing his favorite computer games and he agreed. After playing for a while, he became frustrated with Wizards 101 and, after some persuasion, he switched to Poptropica. It appears that B.S.R. does not worry about remembering his personas in this game, he just makes up a new one each time he plays, unlike Wizards in which he has a set avatar and a set character.
Reflections
I decided that in order to better understand my study subjects I should play some of the games that they told me they liked to play and read some of the books they liked to read.
I logged onto the Poptropica site and signed in as a new player. I was assigned the name Messy Icicle and preceded to play on different islands. The first few were rather easy, once I got into the feel of the game and learned a few “cheats” from one of the websites recommended by one of my study subjects. As the islands progressed, however, they appeared to get more difficult to navigate. I know that at least one of my study subjects found the newer islands to be quite frustrating, as he told me so. As far as Wizards 101 goes, I did not even attempt to try to play the game. After watching B.S.R. play for almost an hour, I still am quite confused about why it is so popular and as to exactly how it is played. I found it extremely frustrating and confusing. Perhaps, I should try it again, someday, but for now I am giving it a miss and moving onto something else. I prefer word games, myself.
I read the first Percy Jackson & the Olympians book, The Lightning Thief, and enjoyed it very much. Luckily, I had read it before my first interview session with B.S.R. so that I could understand what he was talking about when he told me how he felt about the changes the filmmakers made when turning The Lightning Thief into a movie.
I also read two of the Artemis Fowl book series, but did not enjoy them at all. Perhaps it is because I am not a fifth grade boy. I actually found them a bit boring, pedantic, and unbelievably silly. I don’t know why I have been able to suspend my disbelief while reading other books, but had a very difficult time believing that a fourteen year old boy could be so powerful a criminal mastermind.
Interviewing the boys from Mr. W.’s fifth grade class, began as rather frustrating, as they do tend to talk all at the same time and keep interrupting one another as well as me; however, by the end, I found myself quite enjoying myself. I feel that I have learned a lot more about computer games (they did not have them when I was in fifth grade) and about juvenile literature, as well. I now feel like I am on my way to becoming a Rick Riordan fan and plan to read the entire Percy Jackson & the Olympians series, when I get the chance. Maybe I will add the books to my Summer Reading list, and then I will move on to the Red Pyramid. It sounds like a really good story, from what the boys have been telling me.
Community Profile
According to the census taken in 2000, the total population of Los Angeles, California was 3,694,820. The male population was 1,841,805, or 49.8 percent of the total population of the community. The median age of people living in Los Angeles, California was 31.6. The number of people under the age of 5 was 285,976, compared to 2,713,509, which was the number of people living in Los Angeles over the age of 18. The “racial” breakdown of the population was 1,734, 036 or 46.9 percent “White”, 415,195 or 11.2 percent “Black”, 29,412 American Indian and Alaska Native, 369,254 Asian, and 5,915 Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander. The number of people who identified as “Other”/Multiple, and those the government considered to be identified as “some other race”, was 949,720, and 1,719,073 or 46.5 percent, were Hispanic/Latino. The average family size was 3.56. At the time of 2000 census survey, 1,538,715 people or 66.6 percent had a high school diploma. Only 589,061 people, or 25.5 percent of the total population in Los Angeles, California, at that time, had a Bachelor’s degree or higher. The median household income was reported to be $36,687 versus $41,994 nationwide. The median family income was $39,942 versus $50,046 nationwide. According to the National Center for Education Statistics website, there are 778 public schools in the city of Los Angeles, and the one I chose to study, in just one of them. (AmericanTowns.com, 2011).
I find it amazing that with all of the information I found out about Los Angeles, I was lucky enough to find a group of fifth grade boys who actually still enjoy reading. The year 2000 was the year most of the boys in the group I studied were born. They originally came from various cultures, families of origin, traditions, beliefs, and ancestry; but they all seemed to be interested in the same kinds of games and the same kinds of books. I find that to be very interesting. Maybe it is true that we are all more alike than we are different.


References
The boys of Mr. W.’s Fifth Grade Class.
B.S.R., (my nephew).
“Los Angeles, CA.” Los Angeles Census & Community Profile. AmericanTowns.com. (April 2011). Retrieved from www.americantowns.com/ca/losangeles-information.
Search for Public Schools. CCD: Common Core of Data. National Center for Education Statistics. Retrieved from nces.ed.gov/.


No comments:

Post a Comment