Thursday, August 12, 2010

Mystery story for kids


Sparrows in the Scullery
by Barbara Brooks Wallace

Synopsis: Newly orphaned Colin "Colley" Trevelyan is kidnapped from his bed and taken to the Broggin Home for Boys where he is given the name "Jed Broggin" and is made to work in a Victorian era glass factory, wear rags and eat stew made from rotten vegetables and meat scraps. At first, the other boys in the home ignore him or are very cruel, but eventually, they warm up to him and even help him to adjust to his new life. When Colley becomes ill, the boys hide him in an underground tunnel, with their pet rat "Abigail" and a back exit to the local graveyard. When the underground hideout is discovered by the administrators of the boys home, Colley must flee only to be caught again. This time, however, he is taken to the home of his cousin Jeremy who helps Colley to solve the mystery of his abduction and to retrieve his inheritance from his father's brother who wanted it all for himself. In the end, Colley is returned to his home to be taken care of by servants and his five new friends from Broggin are allowed to join him.

Wallace, B.W. (1997, 2006) Sparrows in the Scullery. Lincoln, NE: iUniverse, Inc.

Image of book cover retrieved from amazon.co.uk.

Personal Impressions: I liked this story, although it was a little to short and the mystery solved a little too easily for my adult tastes. I think this book might appeal to older elementary and some middle school students who enjoy mysteries.

Reviews:

Grade 4-6...Reminiscent of Joan Aiken's The Wolves of Willoughby Chase (Yearling, 1987), the book is populated with characters who are either very good or horrible. Wallace writes well, balancing the educated dialogue of Colley with the course language of the street boys. A secret room, a pet rat, and near mishaps add to the intrigue. Although the ending is a little sweet, Wallace ties together most loose ends and includes some unsolved problems. Readers will gobble up this satisfying fare.

Mary M. Hopf, Los Angeles Public Library, School Library Journal, 1997.


Wallace (Cousins in the Castle, 1996, etc.) transports readers back to 19th-century England, to the time when it was not uncommon for orphans to be sold to seemingly charitable homes where they were clothed and fed, but where they were often required to toil long hours in factories...The action takes off at a horse's gallop: After his parents are killed in a carriage accident, Colley is kidnapped and sold to the Broggin Home for Boys. There he is stripped of his name and put to work in a glass factory...Wallace is deliberately Dickensian in her portrait of the home and the boys, yet the tale is full of hope: The boys find an unexpected savior, and readers will be borne along by the suspense to an exhilarating conclusion. (Fiction. 8-12)

Kirkus Reviews, 1997.

Above reviews retrieved from http://www.amazon.com/Sparrows-Scullery-Barbara-Brooks-Wallace/dp/0689815859.

Suggestions for use in a library setting: This could be a good book to recommend to elementary and middle school-aged readers, second to eighth grade, who like mysteries that are not too scary or complicated.

No comments:

Post a Comment