Thursday, August 12, 2010

Perseverence and self-esteem in young women

The Midwifes Apprentice.jpg
The Midwife's Apprentice
by Karen Cushman

Synopsis: One evening, a homeless, orphaned girl, named "Brat", finds a warm place to sleep in a dung heap. She is found by the village midwife, Jane, given the name "Beetle", and put to work as the midwife's apprentice. Beetle fetches and carries and puts up with the midwife's sharp tongue, but also watches and learns. She rescues and adopts an orange tabby cat, simply called "Purr", befriends one of the boys in the village, helps another homeless child find a home and a job, and gives herself a new name. Now preferring to be called Alyce, the girl soon finds herself called upon to act as midwife when Jane the Midwife decides to leave one young mother in labor to attend to someone richer and better able to pay. When she makes too many mistakes, Alyce believes she is too stupid and runs away, only to find a position in an alehouse. Eventually, her past catches up with her and she must decide who she really wants to be: Brat the stupid, homeless girl, or Alyce, the capable midwife's apprentice. After successfully delivering a baby, Alyce finds the answer to her question and returns to work with Jane the Midwife, and learns not to give up and when you fail to try and try again.

Cushman, K. (1995). The Midwife's Apprentice. New York, NY: Harper Trophy.

The above book cover image was retrieved from Wikipedia.com.

Personal Impressions: Even though this story is set in what appears to be the middle ages in a village in Europe somewhere, I believe that modern readers, especially elementary school-aged girls, will find something familiar about the protagonist, Brat, called Beetle, and then Alyce. She is a girl not that different from girls who live today, and is very sympathetic. In the Midwife's Apprentice, Alyce is struggling with identity and figuring out who she is and what she wants to be in the world. She is not perfect and makes mistakes, but she learns that one cannot give up just because they make mistakes. She learns to learn from her mistakes and to keep trying until she gets it right. I think that many young girls will like reading about Alyce and her adventures. In my opinion, this book is long enough to be appealing to young, independent readers, but still short enough not to be too challenging to them. It does not have any illustrations, but the narrative works to provide the words to help readers develop the images in their imaginations as they read. It is not a perfect book, but I enjoyed reading it. I recommend it for second to eighth grade students.

The Midwife's Apprentice has won several awards including, the Newbery Award in 1996, ALA Notable Children's Book in 1996, ALA Best Book for Young Adults in 1996, 1995 New York Public Library List of Recommended Books, Booklist "Books for Youth Editor's Choice", School Library Journal Best Books of the Year, 1995, and American Bookseller Association Pick of the Lists.

Reviews:

Karen Cushman likes to write with her tongue firmly planted in her cheek, and her feisty female characters firmly planted in history. In The Midwife's Apprentice, which earned the 1996 Newbery Medal, this makes a winning combination for children and adult readers alike. Like her award-winning book Catherine, Called Birdy, the story takes place in medieval England. This time our protagonist is Alyce, who rises from the dung heap (literally) of homelessness and namelessness to find a station in life--apprentice to the crotchety, snaggletoothed midwife Jane Sharp. On Alyce's first solo outing as a midwife, she fails to deliver. Instead of facing her ignorance, Alyce chooses to run from failure--never a good choice. Disappointingly, Cushman does not offer any hardships or internal wrestling to warrant Alyce's final epiphanies, and one of the book's climactic insights is when Alyce discovers that lo and behold she is actually pretty! Still, Cushman redeems her writing, as always, with historical accuracy, saucy dialogue, fast-paced action, and plucky, original characters that older readers will eagerly devour. (Ages 12 and older)

Gail Hudson, amazon.com


In reviewing this 1996 Newbery winner, PW said that Cushman "has an almost unrivaled ability to build atmosphere, and her evocation of a medieval village, if not scholarly in its authenticity, is supremely colorful and pungent." Ages 8-12.

Publishers Weekly, (1996).

Both of these reviews were retrieved from: http://www.amazon.com/Midwifes-Apprentice-Karen-Cushman/dp/006440630X/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1281606865&sr=1-1

Suggestions for use in a library setting: This book could be recommended to second to eighth grade students who are interested in stories about girls coming into their own. It also could be recommended to students who are learning about life during the Middle Ages in Europe, although, some of the reviews I read suggested that Karen Cushman was not always historically accurate in her descriptions of village life during that time.

No comments:

Post a Comment