by Russell Martin and Lydia Nibley
Synopsis: When Ludwig van Beethoven died, in 1827, a young musician named Ferdinand Hiller came to pay his respects to the great composer. In those days, it was customary to snip a lock of hair as a keepsake, and Beethoven allowed the young man, as well as others to do just that. No one knows what happened to the other locks of Beethoven's hair, but one of them was encased in a frame and began a journey, passing from hand to hand, through three generations, landing in Nazi-occupied Denmark during World War II, and ultimately ending up in Arizona, in the United States of America, in 1995. In this book, Russel Martin and his wife, Lydia Nibley, relate the story of the origin of the lock of Beethoven's hair and some of the story of the great composer's life, as well as how the lock of hair came to be purchased by Dr. Alfredo "Che" Guevara and businessman Ira Brilliant. The book has since been made into a documentary, and the lock of hair now resides at California State University at San Jose.
Martin, R. and Nibley, L. (2009). The Mysteries of Beethoven's Hair. Watertown, MA: Charlesbridge Publishing.
Review:
Grade 5–8—Based on Martin's adult book Beethoven's Hair: An Extraordinary Historical Odyssey and Scientific Mystery Solved (Broadway, 2000), this reworking for a young audience presents an intriguing interdisciplinary story. Martin and Nibley trace the labyrinthine journey of a lock of Beethoven's hair encased in a glass and wooden locket from the 18th century to the present. Using a balanced mix of verifiable research and some conjecture, they explain the lock's odyssey over time and how it was ultimately acquired by two American Beethoven aficionados in 1994. The perseverance and passion of these men provided the impetus for scientific analysis to seek a physiological explanation for Beethoven's lifelong struggle with myriad physical and emotional problems. The contemporary story of the lock's travels and examination is interspersed with the history of Beethoven's musical genius. Aspects of the Holocaust and the courageous defiance of the Nazis by the Danish resistance become a significant part of the mystery. This is a most unusual, thoroughly researched detective story written in a clearly accessible and lively tone. Black-and-white photos and reproductions appear throughout. Concluding notes offer young people advice about research and explain what narrative nonfiction is and how the authors used it in this book. Though obviously a selection suited for research projects, it is also an incredibly readable and absorbing selection that demonstrates the multidimensional nature of true scholarship.Renee Steinberg, formerly at Fieldstone Middle School, Montvale, NJ, School Library Journal.
Above review retrieved from http://www.amazon.com/Mysteries-Beethovens-Hair-Russell-Martin/dp/1570917140#_.
Suggestions for use in a library setting: I feel that this book would be most appropriate for high school and college-aged readers, although another reviewer has recommended it for middle school students. Read it and decide for yourself. It could be utilized as research for a biographical paper on Beethoven, forensic techniques, or genealogical research. The longer book, by Russell Martin, one of the authors of this book, could be appropriate for older teens, young adults, and adults, as well as middle students who are more advanced readers, and/or have more of an interest in Beethoven, his life, and the manner of his death.
No comments:
Post a Comment